In these holy, awe-filled moments, the congregation has intimate fellowship with Jesus Christ. The communion hymn(s) should reflect the significance of this fellowship, and serve to maintain a holy and peaceful atmosphere. Songs should be invitational (we are invited to the table of Christ), contemplative, present-focused, and centered on Christ. These songs are not about us—they’re all about Him.
During the dispensation of Holy Communion, consider having just the piano or organ play a few verses of a hymn so that the initial atmosphere is one of meditation and reflection (a vocal or instrumental solo could also work well here, or this could follow the piano/organ solo). Then, once all (or most) members have received communion, the congregation could sing a hymn together that is more upbeat and celebratory in nature (this could either be an extension of the same hymn, or another song that is similar/connected). Another option when it comes to the congregation hymn, especially if a more modern song is used and a vocal soloist is leading, is to have the congregation join only on the chorus (again, once all or most members have received communion).
Some examples of appropriate communion hymns include: Beautiful, Glorious Moment; I Praise God’s Love in Adoration; I Will Sing of My Redeemer; Blessed Assurance; Behold the Lamb (Communion Hymn), and The Lord Is My Salvation.
It is vital that these moments not be rushed, and that they are given the time that underscores the significance of the sacrament. The last person receiving Holy Communion should be given the same opportunity as the first: to receive the sacrament, return to their seat, and be able to express their thanksgiving through prayer and song. If the communion hymn ends as the last person is sitting, we have not given them an opportunity to do this and have rushed their communion with Jesus and the congregation.
The accompanist should be careful not to end the song abruptly, nor extend it unnecessarily, but rather come to an appropriate ending after the members of the congregation have received communion and the chalices are back on the altar. This may be the time when an extended postlude or a repeat of the chorus may help to create these feelings of peace and completion.
For more guiding thoughts related to Holy Communion music, click here